Agency or software? The honest answer is 'it depends what you are buying'




Two different things wearing one invoice
A retainer typically covers two kinds of work, priced as one.
Repetitive work. Auditing the site, fixing tags, posting content, chasing reviews, assembling the monthly report. Necessary, valuable, and the same every month.
Judgement. Knowing your trade. Spotting that your best customers come from somewhere nobody expected. Telling you the campaign you are excited about will not work. Picking up the phone when you are worried.
Software does the first well and the second not at all. An agency does both, and you pay agency rates for both.
The question to ask
"Roughly what share of your hours on my account goes to work that is the same every month?"
A good agency will answer honestly, because it is usually most of it and they know it. That number tells you what you are actually buying.
If it is 80% repetitive, software plus occasional advice is better value. If it is genuinely strategic — new markets, positioning, a complicated sale — keep the agency.
The option most people miss
Keep the agency and give them the software.
They stop spending half the retainer on audits and reports and spend it on work that needs a person. You get both. Several of our customers do exactly this, and the agencies tend to like it — repetitive work is not what good people want to do either.
Signs you are paying for the wrong thing
- The monthly report leads with impressions.
- You cannot name a decision that changed because of their advice.
- The work is visible in a task list but not in your diary.
- Asking which bookings came from their work produces discomfort.
None of these mean the agency is dishonest. It usually means you bought a retainer when you needed a tool.
What to do before you cancel anything
Do not switch on instinct. Spend one month measuring, and the decision makes itself.
Ask for the work log, not the report. What was actually done, in hours. Most agencies will provide it. The split between repetitive and strategic is usually obvious at a glance.
Count your own unanswered enquiries. If a quarter of enquiries are going unanswered, no amount of agency work fixes your month — the leak is after the marketing, and that is yours to fix either way.
Pick three phrases that matter and track them yourself. Not the agency's list of fourteen hundred. Three that would genuinely bring you work. Watch them for a month in Search Console, which is free and takes ten minutes to set up.
Then have the conversation. With the hours, the unanswered count and the three phrases in front of you, it is no longer a negotiation about value. It is a factual discussion about where effort should go — and good agencies welcome that, because it is the conversation they have been trying to have.
The middle path most people miss
You do not have to choose. Keep the strategic relationship, take the repetitive work in-house with software, and reduce the retainer to match. The agency gets to do the work they are good at, you stop paying agency rates for tag fixes, and nobody has to fire anybody.